Vital Football

Latest Hibs News

Time For Petrie & Butcher To Go

Time For Petrie & Butcher To Go

So the dust is beginning to settle on Hibs relegation from the Premiership with the release of the majority of the playing squad yet the biggest culprits still loom large over the club.

Chairman Rod Petrie remains and is defiant in the face of criticism and the management 'dream team' of Terry Butcher, Maurice Malpas and Steve Marsella have also somehow escaped the chop.

Much of the malaise at Easter Road can be blamed at the door of Petrie. He's picked a succession of poor quality managers throughout his tenure, with Butcher apparently the latest in a long line.

Spending money on the club's infrastructure rather than investing on the playing field has led to Hibs having a lovely UEFA compliant stadium and a fine training centre yet the team have continually struggled where it counts.

When you look at the facilities it's clear the club should be attempting to lure good quality players from the English lower leagues and attracting the best of the rest from the Premiership yet every manager appears to prefer the signing of journeymen and other miscreants.

A lot of this is down to Petrie who, although he backs his gaffers to a certain degree isn't willing to push the boat out and sign their top targets during the transfer windows which leaves Hibs scrambling about getting other sides cast off's and ill judged loan deals.

Leeann Dempster has been appointed as CEO but Petrie remains in the shadows as non executive Chairman. Will Leeann be given a free hand to make decisions? Will she be able to spend money without interference from above? The support has it's doubts.

After the debacle which was the Scottish Cup final of 2012 we were promised real change at the club. It didn't happen. In fact if it weren't for Leigh Griffiths Hibs may have found themselves in the Championship 12 months earlier - a fact masked by a poor side reaching a second successive cup final.

Despite offering concerns over the playing style of Pat Fenlon, the Irishman was allowed to continue into this season despite an excruciating performance against Malmo in the Europa League.

Fenlon's squad was lop sided. Full of central midfielders and little in the way of defensive or attacking cover. There was never any pace - Hibs were simply a side easy to play against - and beat.

At least Fenlon knew how to get results. It wasn't pretty but by the time he left last November, the side were sitting in the top half of the division and were at least showing some character.

When Terry Butcher was appointed the majority of the support was pleased. He'd taken an Inverness side to second in the league, punching way above their weight and scout Marsella had uncovered some gems from the English leagues.

The Butcher era started with some promise. Victories away to Ross County in the cup, a demolition of Kilmarnock at Easter Road then an Edinburgh Derby victory at New Year.

Since then it's been woeful. Stories of unhappy players, a fall out between Butcher's assistant Maurice Malpas and the best player at the club, Kevin Thomson, a run of form which would see any other manager sacked culminating in relegation from the Premiership.

Butcher's overall record at Easter Road is cringeworthy. Six wins from 29 games with 15 losses. The last 21 have seen Hibs win twice and one of them was against Hamilton.

It's been clear for months the players weren't buying into his ideas. The fans certainly aren't. They're sick of watching an assault on the football each week as the ball is hoofed aimlessly up the park, sometimes to be chased by a man in green - other times to be caught by someone in the stand.

The whole philosophy at Easter Road needs to be changed. There was a start yesterday when the players, who have to shoulder the blame equally were emptied but the changes need to go deeper.

Petrie needs to leave and give Dempster free reign. Butcher, Malpas and Marsella need to leave as they'll never gain the supporters trust again following relegation.

Neither the Chairman or management team have shown they have what it takes to turn the club around and restore it's Premiership ambitions.

There's a chance to start afresh with a blank canvass - it must be taken or rewarding mediocrity and failure has won.

Vital Hibs is now available on both facebook and twitter, so if you are that way inclined give us a follow or a like!

Vital Hibs on: facebook

Vital Hibs on: twitter

Join Vital Hibernian

It's easy to REGISTER HERE, simply click the link and enjoy getting involved!

Win FREE pizza with Vital Football!
Select your team and get 50% off if they score twice.
www.papajohns.co.uk/football
Writer:Franck_Sauzee
Date:Tuesday May 27 2014
Time: 10:08AM

Best of Vital Scottish Football

Comments

0
Many valid points in there. If Butcher doesn't walk then he's got to be sacked. His gross mismanagement has put Hibs where they are. He's a clown and I won't be back under his watch. I thought we'd turned the corner after the 1st leg then Sunday saw possibly the worst performance ever and I include Malmo and 5-1 in that. The man is a failure.
bennybrazil
27/05/2014 15:28:00
Page 1/1
  1. 1

Login to post a comment

Recent Hibernian Articles

Trio In Team Of The Season 2015/16

Hibernian are represented in the Scottish Professional Football League Championship team of the season that has been selected after the end of the current campaign.

Who Will Hibernian Face In 2016/17 (24/5/16)

With no matches remaining in the regular 2015/16 campaign, the make up of the Championship is now known with Falkirk missing out on promotion at the weekend.

Hibernian - European Entrants 2016/17

With eyes turning to the 2016/17 campaign, here's who the Scottish Professional Football League will have representing them in European competition.

Stubbs - We Deserved Rangers Victory

Manager Alan Stubbs has said he felt Hibernian deserved their Scottish Cup victory over Rangers on Saturday.

Archived Vital Hibs Articles

Vital Hibs articles from

Site Journalists

Al
no email
Profile

Current Poll (see more polls)

Scottish Cup Final - Rangers MotM
Suggested By:
Logan2%
McGregor0%
Hanlon0%
Fontaine0%
Gray14%
Fyvie0%
McGeouch0%
McGinn8%
Stevenson0%
Stokes74%
Cummings0%
Sub - Keatings0%
Sub - Henderson2%
Sub - Gunnarsson0%

League Table

# Team P W D L Pts. GD
1 Celtic 38 26 8 4 86 62
2 Aberdeen 38 22 5 11 71 14
3 Hearts 38 18 11 9 65 19
4 St. Johnstone 38 16 8 14 56 3
5 Motherwell 38 15 5 18 50 -16
6 Ross County 38 14 6 18 48 -6
7 Inverness 38 14 10 14 52 6
8 Dundee 38 11 15 12 48 -4
9 Partick 38 12 10 16 46 -9
10 Hamilton 38 11 10 17 43 -21
11 Kilmarnock 38 9 9 20 36 -23
12 Dundee United 38 8 7 23 28 -25
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News

Recent Hibernian Results (view all)

Hibernian Fixtures (view all)