Hibernian - Have Hibs Fallen Behind Already?
UK time is: 22:35:19
Vital Login
Social Login

Choose your club

Other Sites

Network Navigation

Vital Partners

'If It's Football, It's Vital'

Have Hibs Fallen Behind Already?

A threadbare squad has returned to Hibs training centre at East Mains to begin preparations for the season ahead although with many clubs already having started to sign players for the new campaign, the Easter Road outfit are yet to confirm their manager (granted this will likely happen tomorrow) so will the Hibees promotion prospects be hampered by the delay in sacking Terry Butcher and the subsequent wait to appoint, presumably, Alan Stubbs?

Hibs face two main challengers in the race for promotion, Rangers and Hearts, with both having made at least one potentially match winning signing.

Meantime in Leith, one of Butcher's final decisions as boss, and arguably his best, was to release 11 of the playing squad which failed both him and the supporters last season.

Factor in the sale of James Collins to Shrewsbury then it's not difficult to imagine the benefits an early appointee could have had when it boiled down to the playing staff.

Of course, there are reasons for the current situation with new CEO Leeann Dempster correctly wishing to evaluate the club prior to making any decisions after her arrival at the beginning of the month.

So far she's made a perfectly good call on Butcher's fate, made promising noises regarding the full re-structuring of the footballing side of operations and looks happy to enter into dialogue with the fans on an on-going basis.

However this doesn't detract from what many fans believe is a foolhardy position for Hibs to be found in.

Ahead of a season when the Scottish second tier will be stronger than at any point in it's history, Hibernian are currently in a position where they have no recognised goalkeeper or genuine right back on the books whilst other positions are covered by more of last season's failed squad.

There was a hope, once the majority of the team which capitulated into relegation fodder during the second half of the 2013/14 had been released, new additions would be made quickly and the players would be primed from the very beginning of pre season training and raring to go when the big kick off got underway.

Clearly things haven't panned out as most supporters would have liked although the retention of another of Butcher's backroom staff, Steve Marsella, who has apparently been allowed to continue in his role of Chief Scout, could prove to be a master stroke.

He was famed for bringing many low profile names to Inverness during his time there (with Billy McKay the biggest steal of all) where they were transformed into genuine top flight quality players, and Marsella's services will surely be utilised by the new manager upon arrival.

Hibs have had some lavish failures over the past few years under a succession of managers so in order to pull some of the fans back onside need to show their true ambition when they state they want to head back to the Premiership at the first time of action.

Should they spend big in relative Championship terms with a marquee signing or two (James McFadden anyone?), season tickets will soon rise to comparable levels from previous years and the more bums on seats the more money is generated for the transfer budget.

This pre season is the biggest the Hibees have faced in years, it's about time the new man was confirmed and set about business without interference or penny pinching from above.

Vital Hibs is available on all social media platforms including Twitter, Facebook, SportsYapper and Instagram - Follow or like us by clicking the links below!

Vital Hibs on: facebook

Vital Hibs on: twitter

Join Vital Hibernian

It's easy to REGISTER HERE, simply click the link and enjoy getting involved!

Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

The Journalist

Writer: Franck_Sauzee  Mail feedback, articles or suggestions

Date:Monday June 23 2014

Time: 8:55PM

Your Comments (oldest first)

Change to most recent first
Sorry to be so pessimistic but I am dreading the start of the new season. We have almost the entire team that started against Hamilton still in the squad and were putting our faith in a man whos only experience of management is with youth players, admittedly Premiership players but youth players nonetheless. Imagine the first mistake someone like Ryan McGivern makes! The fans will come down on him hard then that same fear of playing at home will flow through the team. Not "again" as that fear has been in the team for about four years now. Its all looking painfully familiar and unless the club have found a pot of gold somwhere I just can't see us getting out of this mess anytime soon. Just going onto the Hibs site and looking at our "squad" today, well you will all know what I mean when you take a look yourselves!
John Scott1
Report Abuse
24/06/2014 09:26:00

John I'm another who is fearful for the season ahead. The players left at the club are the ones guilty of causing relegation and you can feel the witch hunt boiling beneath the surface in regards to certain players such as Nelson, McGivern and Craig. This news article makes a fine point regarding our ultimate goal for next season. If Ms Dempster believes we can go up at the first time of asking she has to back her man and 'marquee' signings could win over her Petrie's stooge doubters. 2 quality signings in the spine of the team are required.
Cramond Hibee
Report Abuse
24/06/2014 10:27:00

The pessimism surrounding the club since the end of the club has remained with no end in sight. Hibs currently have no manager, no sponsor, no home strip on sale, very few players and season ticket sales are dreadful. Any commercial director would be distraught at the delays over all the point made but we just keep meandering on and on. The darkness needs to be lifted so it's about time things were sorted out. Get the announcement made today or if there's a problem let us know. And let his know why there's a problem.
Report Abuse
24/06/2014 11:08:00

Not sure how old you are Cramond but I witnessed the two previous relegations. Despite a hiccup against Stranraer at our first home game the last time we went down, we sailed through the league. Big travelling supports during both visits to the lower league pushed us onwards and upwards. This time will be completely different. I still think we'll have a large travelling support but the Hibs board need to research Dunfermline. Leishmans eighties team had a massive travelling support. One of the largest in Scottish football. A charismatic manager and truly loyal fans. Now look at them. If our board and a large section of our support think for one minute we cant end up like them??? So if any of the board are reading this you better get a grip and buy some decent players. Thats players with bottle, craft and guile. Not free transfers from Accrington or Matlock by the way!!! Cmon you Hibees!!!
John Scott1
Report Abuse
24/06/2014 12:34:00

Sorry, one final point: Yes Inverness did find a few gems in the lower English leagues. However their squad has players in it that didnt quite make it. Like our gamble with our manager the players that Marsella will bring in will be gambles too. Why are we gambling with our clubs future?
John Scott1
Report Abuse
24/06/2014 12:48:00

Some excellent points in there John. I'm guessing by your comments you're 40+ like myself as I remember being exceptionally impressed when Dunfermline travelled to Easter Road in the 80's and filled what was then the Dunbar End. I was only small at the time but it was the largest away support I'd ever seen! Your comparison actually made me shudder at the thought of Hibs ending up like the Pars and while I hope it's not going to happen, as an example it proves it isn't impossible. I agree on the recruitment drive - journeymen signings should be a thing of the past and we all want to see an appetite in the players which has been lacking in recent seasons but I fear budget constraints and the time taken to appoint a new boss will hinder us in that regard. Most decent players will already have entered into preliminary discussions at least with clubs if they're free agents which, let's face it, is our signing market at this time. Stubbs has to be backed by the board and the parachute payment should help matters but unless we show some ambition the stay away fans will be exactly that. Every signing represents a gamble but if they're at least hungry for success then that should be the very minimum attribute of potential additions to the squad.
Report Abuse
24/06/2014 14:06:00

Sorry guys but we will never allow ourselves to become another Dunfermline. If we don't get promoted this year then I'd expect both the Huns and the yams to go up and then I'd expect a big investment next summer to bring in sufficient players of quality to have a promotion charge McLeish style. We'll be 2 years max in the championship.
Report Abuse
24/06/2014 22:39:00


Have Your Say

Log in...
with your social network     OR     with your Vital account

Recent Hibernian Articles

Stubbs Interest Will Come (Thursday November 26 2015)

Video - Alloa Highlights (a) (Monday November 23 2015)

Stats: Alloa v Hibernian (Saturday November 21 2015)

Alloa v Hibernian - Team Line Ups (Saturday November 21 2015)

Vital Preview - Alloa v Hibernian (Saturday November 21 2015)

Stats: Hibernian v Livingston (Tuesday November 17 2015)

Vital Preview - Hibernian v Livingston (Tuesday November 17 2015)

Interest In Cummings Grows (Monday November 16 2015)

St Johnstone Semi Date Set (Saturday November 14 2015)

McGinn Backs Title Challenge (Saturday November 14 2015)

Archived Hibernian Articles

List All Vital Hibs Articles
Have your say
Click here to suggest an article
Click here to suggest a poll

Vital Members League (view all)

1. Nribs 1

Breaking League News

Petrofac Training Cup - Rangers v St Mirren
Rangers : 27/11/2015 19:04:01
Vital Preview - Motherwell v Hearts
Hearts : 27/11/2015 18:38:01
Vital Preview - Aberdeen v Ross County
Aberdeen : 27/11/2015 18:20:01
United bring in forward
Dundee United : 27/11/2015 14:14:01
Striker holds up hands
Celtic : 27/11/2015 12:28:00

Current Site Poll (view all polls)

Alloa MotM
Suggested By:  Site Staff
Oxley 0%
Gray 20%
Fontaine 0%
McGregor 0%
Stevenson 0%
Bartley 0%
Fyvie 0%
McGinn 20%
Keatings 0%
Cummings 0%
Malonga 0%
Sub - El Alagui 0%
Sub - McGeouch 60%
Sub - Boyle 0%